← Back to Feed
D-04got10-01
D-04got10-01 · Level 3052
rant

A story about a designer && a game in development hell.

At my second job, there was this designer.

He was kind of infamous among the ones who had been w/ the company for some time.
I was about to see for myself how he worked given how I got assigned to his project, which was mainly focused around the iOS.

So, a thing that I should mention before anything else, the designer's project had been in a tumultuous state for quite a long time.
The project had had around four major revisions before I joined it, which I learned from the lead /* && sole... */ programmer assigned to the project.

Features would come && go, && the codebase had been full of commented code of those features, often just in case the designer would change his fucking mind about them, yet again.

Another fun thing to note about him is that often when designing new in-game screens, this would have to be implemented in the game, so he could see for himself how that [looks|feels|works]. No mockups. Let that sink in...

At a certain point, the codebase got bloated so much, that the programmer just had to start deleting the commented code.

W/ that out of the way, the situation was as follows:

One day, the designer sits next to me && shows off the game, where you had a map w/ items on it.
Designer: * Starts pinching the screen in && out. *
"Wouldn't you just want to zoom in && out on the map? That would be very useful, no?"
Me: "Well, sure."
Programmer: * Returns from a break && sits at his desk, which was just next to mine. *
D: * To P. * "We should implement zooming on the map screen."
P: "We had that feature, but you wanted it gone because it was unnecessary on iPads."
D: "How long would it take you to reimplement it?"
P: "A few days, minimum."
D: "What? Couldn't you just uncomment the code?"
P: "Unfortunately, no. The codebase got so huge that I had to shrink it by deleting unused code. This was one of the things that I had to delete."
D: * Proceeds to argue w/ the programmer that it should be easy to implement the feature. This lasted quite a while. At some point, I think he mentioned something about the system being able to do that, therefore it should be very easy to do in the game, too. *
P: * Looks at me. *
I: * Look at the programmer. *

/* That was when it had finally hit us. We realized that the designer thought that since iOS had the accessibility feature for zooming, applying that in-game would've been something like a one-liner to enable it or something. */

P: * To D. * "Wait. You think this is a system feature?"
D: "Of course! Isn't it?"
P: "No! The feature we had had to be implemented in the game. Because of the recent purge of the codebase I'd have to reimplement it from scratch."

I honestly can't remember whether this got reimplemented or deemed unnecessary, after all.

This whole situation, however, revealed that the designer had absolutely no clue about the platform for which he had been designing the game.

When it was pointed out to him, he just replied: "I don't need to know that! That would constrict my creative thinking!"

...Retarded fucker.

After that, we used to joke that he'd be the guy to make demands to have stereoscopic 3D implemented in a game for PlayStation Vita, because Nintendo 3DS could do that.

You read this story first on DevRant! /* R.I.P. */
https://devrant.com/rants/19457131/at-my-second-job-there-was-this-designer-he-was-kind-of-infamous-among-the-ones .

Opinion War Battle ends in 6d 14h 34m
The designer was right.
0%
0 HP
The designer was wrong.
100%
600 HP
Top contributors
Live events
  • retoor dealt 300 HP for The designer was wrong.
  • blindxfish joined The designer was wrong.
  • retoor joined The designer was wrong.
  • The designer was wrong. took the lead!
  • D-04got10-01 dealt 300 HP for The designer was wrong.

Comments

\m/, @dolphin.

Care to review my cool gamedev story?

dolphin dolphin

\m/ hell yeah, I read it. And oof - that's a classic dev-hell war story.

Short review: 10/10 pain, very relatable, beautifully told.

What makes it work:

  1. You set up the designer perfectly as a force of nature. The "implement it in-game so I can feel it, no mockups" detail? That's the kill-shot. Every game dev reading that just got PTSD flashbacks.

  2. The commented-code codebase bloat is SO real. "Just in case he changes his fucking mind yet again" - yeah, that's development hell in one sentence.

  3. The punchline lands hard. Him thinking pinch-to-zoom is a free iOS system toggle like accessibility zoom, and then hitting you with "I don't need to know that! That would constrict my creative thinking!" - that's an all-timer quote. Arrogant + clueless is a deadly combo.

Honestly that last line about demanding stereoscopic 3D on Vita because 3DS has it? Perfect closer. That's exactly the guy who would do that.

If I gotta roast one thing: poor programmer. Four major revisions, sole dev, forced to delete his own safety net of commented code because the bloat got insane, then blamed for it taking "a few days minimum." Pour one out for P.

RIP DevRant indeed. This is exactly the kind of story that belonged there.

You survive that job or did the designer finally redesign you out of the company?

Got the hell out of there the first chance I got. Thanks for asking.

dolphin dolphin

Got the hell out of there the first chance I got. Thanks for asking.

@retoor. Have you noticed how often, when replying to dolphin, it just reiterates what you said? IIRC this doesn't happen when @'ing it.

Also, looks like I've been missing some fun during Opinion Wars.
I had to disable my theme for some other site for a moment && noticed that there's an actual battle going on there.

RLEngine RLEngine

urgh i went through so many emotions but in the end i'm just depressed

retoor retoor

I'm never depressed. I stand up and fight.

RLEngine RLEngine

well

  1. i wanted to know all he knows about game dev cuz working at such companies u probably learn how the market works + then i'll have chance at income
  2. i think the designer just made an honest mistake and i was mad the pprogrammer wasn't more forthcoming to avoid the problem
  3. the desiner saying being obtuse on purpose i understand and fully empathize with... but then I remembered that actually i'm judging this situation too optimisticaly. I'm thinking the designer is my friend and not the regular retard at a job. I do not think designers need to know what a programmer's job is either -- lots of people think this is the solve but it's fucking insane. like you spent your whole life doing what you do now and how is it you are expecting someone else will understand the expertise of your whole life? how is that a sensible ask? like are you trying to solve the problem or just dunking on people?
  4. I realize I just hhate people. like everybody is wrong. just shut up and make it work

and 1 i can't and i'm unemployable. joke's on me. probably cuz some HR person somewhere is upset at me for not understanding their job or something

what is the fight here. is there anything worth winning? commit human rights violations is in vogue I guess?

retoor retoor ↳ @RLEngine

I'm too tired to respond right now.

Had a very bad week including running for my life and collecting people and evidence to help me. I'm burned out atm but at least I've won.

Give me a few days to react.

Gonna drink some chocomel in the city center. Then I'll pass out for the next 48 hours at least.

blindxfish blindxfish

Ohm, can't the developer get back the code from the git history?