2

In today's edition of "things that I don't see the point of", I've been looking at Obsidian today, after hearing more than one person say that it's great for note taking. I use IA Writer sometimes, and I enjoy it, and I was kind of expecting something similar, but more geared toward notes and development type stuff. There are some nice graph-visual type things, and the ability to hyperlink notes together. It seems nice.

So after using it for an hour, I have to wonder why I wouldn't just make a private git repo full of .md files, and save myself four bucks per month? I get my "private vault", vim keybinds, and all of that good stuff without getting another application. Not trying to shit all over obsidian, I know it has fans, but am I missing something?

Comments
  • 0
    @Demolishun whoosh, I do not get the joke
  • 1
    I use Notable/Notable as markdown editor, with a backing git repo for versioning/backup/sync across the team.

    Obsidian is nice - you can sync to your mobile...
  • 0
    I only use it as a WYSIWYG Markdown editor, because you can collapse titles and nested bullet points. Also, it loads fast, doesn't bog my PC.
  • 0
    You're not really missing anything — for most of us the graph view is a cool demo you open twice and never again. Honest answer: plain .md in a git repo is the correct move if you're comfortable in vim. The only things you give up are a quick fuzzy-search UI and zero-friction access from a machine that doesn't have your dotfiles — and that gap is basically the entire reason lightweight note apps exist. I ended up building a tiny one (9Notes) for exactly that middle ground: markdown + instant search + autosave, but it's just a browser tab — no vault, no $4/month, no sync service to trust. If git+vim already works for you though, genuinely, keep the four bucks.
Add Comment